Not "yet" Sold on the Growth Mindset

Hi there!

Today I want to talk to you guys about the growth mindset videos that we watched. Over all I liked the ideas that Mss. Dweck was presenting but the presentation of her research makes me question the scientific backing of her research.

As I watched the first video “The Power of Believing That You Can Improve,” I thought about my own struggles with education and challenging work. Miss. Dweck’s talk kind of hit home for me as someone who has been obsessive about my grades from a very young age and finds challenging course work more and more intimidating as I have moved through my education. I identified emotionally with a lot of the things she was saying, but when she would show photos to represent her research they didn’t seem to be the most convincing. The photo of the head scans is a very simplified all or nothing photo, which is unusual in research. Additionally, the photo that showed a graph of students grades with and without the growth mindset showed only two data points per set which is not enough to be statistically significant. Granted both photos could have been over simplified for use in this presentation, but they do not lend credibility to her research.

Later, in the same video she also talks about three schools in which “growth mindset” classrooms took classes of students from under-performing to over-performing, but she doesn’t explain the study these results came from which makes her later statement attributing the cause and effect to these results questionable. Granted, again it could just be for the purposes of the TED talk that Miss. Dweck didn’t go into more detail, but it does make me questions the scientific nature of what she is saying.

In the third video she says that a study was done of 373 students transitioning into the 7^th grade, and then discusses that their test scores differed dramatically over time and the only difference between them was their mindsets. While this is an interesting study a sample size of only 373 students is not enough to definitively prove the effectiveness of her mindset approach.

So, while I think that parents should definitely praise their children for effort and perseverance, I am not sold “yet” on the research.

Photo via Flickr by Alberto G.

Comments

Introduction

Hello! My name is Cat and although this will be a blog about mythology and folklore, today I want to tell you all a little bit about myself and my summer. So, to start off I am a civil engineering student here at the University of Oklahoma. I will be graduating in December, but I will be staying on for another year to complete my master’s degree, also in civil engineering but with a focus on structural engineering. Civil engineering includes the design of buildings, infrastructure, water supply systems, waste water treatment systems, and traffic control systems to name a few. Over this summer I had the opportunity to work as an intern for a civil engineering company and learned a lot from the experience. I learned to design pump stations, outline drainage areas, how to do the runoff calculations for inlets, culverts and drainage ditches, and a bunch of stuff about low impact development, but most importantly I learned that I don’t like doing any of those things....

Famous Last Words: Migraines

Hey there! As you may have guessed already because this is an extra credit post, I fell behind last week. This time partially due to procrastination and partially due to a migraine. It was great. Let me tell you about it. I had been feeling really great all week, getting my work done, not too stressed, and like usual I was planning to do the three weekend assignments on Sunday. Yes, I know I shouldn't wait until the last day to do them. Yes, I know this whole thing could have been avoided by doing them early, but hey, hind sight, spilled milk, you know the drill. Plus, I didn't have any other homework due on Monday, unlike usual, so I thought I would have plenty of time. (Here is where the ominous music should play.) However, that afternoon I started having a migraine attack. This quickly spiraled into me sitting and staring at the wall until it stopped later that night. Sadly, I didn't get much work done, as you can imagine. Luckily I am back on my feet today, alth...

Week 2 Story: The Stone Woman

Author's note: I wrote this story after reading Pygmalion and wanting to develop on the statues story. So this story gives the statue a back story, and rewrites some of the original tale, in the form of my character named Ivory. I hope you enjoy it. In ancient Greece there was a woman named Ivory that had grown up in a village far from any city. Her family farmed the land around their home and raised livestock. When she was older, her father would take her with him on the long journey to the city when it was time to sell their crops at the market. One year at the market, Ivory met the most beautiful man she had ever seen. This man’s name was Deveron, and he was known widely for his charm and beauty. Soon after they met, Deveron and Ivory fell in love and were married. They built a small home on the land Ivory’s family owned and continued to farm the land and live good lives that seemed to be blessed by the gods. They were so happy in their love and in their life th...

Mythology Blog

Search This Blog